Jenna's Pie Palace
  • The Recipes
  • "Waitress" Pies
  • Contact

what's inside:
pie recipes inspired by the movie and musical waitress.

sugar... butter... flour.

July 04th, 2016

7/4/2016

4 Comments

 
4 Comments

Got My Vote Rhubarb Compote Pie

7/3/2016

10 Comments

 
Picture

This pie was on the menu board at ART, but was cut before opening night on Broadway. It's 1 of a few delicious-sounding pies that were booted sometime during previews (Scott, I'd love to know why!). It was replaced by Humble Crumble Rhubarb Pie (coming soon...). I can see how this pie might not have been a hit with Joe's diners (it's complex and has a pudding-like texture). But. It is GOOD people! With the lemon and strawberries that I added to the rhubarb compote, it tastes like strawberry lemonade. In a pie. It's sweet and tart, and MUST be served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream atop. This pie definitely got my vote!

Compote is a sauce made from cooking fruit with sugar. I knew a traditional compote wouldn't be thick enough to hold up in a pie, so I did have to add some thickening agents. And while the title of this pie didn't mention any strawberries or lemons, I knew rhubarb on its own would be very sour and not have enough depth to hold up on its own in a compote. This pie was tricky. You can't overcook the compote or the whole fruit will completely dissolve, but you do need to add your thickening agents and give them enough time to firm up the sauce. It was a delicate balance, but it paid off...
Picture
Start with 1lb. of rhubarb...
Picture
...chop into 1in. long pieces.
Picture
Add 1/2 cup of sugar, juice and zest of 1 small lemon.
Picture
Mix 5Tbspn of cornstarch with 1 cup of water.
Picture
Cut up 1 pint of washed strawberries...
Picture
...add them to the rhubarb when you can poke through the rhubarb with a fork. Cook for 2 more mins.
Picture
Let cool to room temperature before filling your blind baked truly flaky crust.
Picture
Once your crust and compote is cool, pour compote into crust. 
Picture
MUST let firm up in fridge for 4+ hours. (Best to let stand overnight, that's when I cut into mine!)
Picture
Slice, and enjoy!! MUST serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. "He gave me ice cream!"
10 Comments

Couch Potato Pie

7/3/2016

21 Comments

 
Picture

Couch Potato Pie. O how I love thee. This pie is a Sunday morning pie. It's a Netflix binge and wearing pajamas all day, not getting up from the couch ever kinda pie. Well you have to get up once. To make this pie. But then it's back to Netflix and season 4 of OITNB. 

​This is a pie featured on Joe's Pie Diner's Menu Board. It is perfect for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, midnight snack... you name it. Wonder if Jenna was thinking of Earl when inventing this pie? Earl seems to inspire many of Jenna's savory pies. Regardless, this pie is mouth watering. I would imagine this one is veryyy popular among the regulars at Joe's.
Picture
Picture
Wash and peel 4 medium Russet potatoes...
Picture
...then slice into 1/8-1/4 inch thick disks.
Picture
Grate some GOOD cheddar cheese.
Picture
Crack your eggs...
Picture
...whisk in milk, salt, and pepper.
Picture
Prepare your truly flaky crust (no blind baking on this one).
Picture
You see that ham in the background? Oh yeah, cube some!
Picture
First layer: grated cheese and smoked ham pieces.
Picture
Second layer: potato slices.
Picture
Layer more cheese and ham, then one more layer of potatoes. This needs to have a generous amount of potatoes. Otherwise it would be called Ham, Cheese, and Egg Couch Pie, right?
Picture
Pour egg mixture into your layers of ham, cheese, and potatoes.
Picture
Picture
Let sit for 15 mins before cutting into this beautiful thing. Once you do, you'll see. It's majestic. Okay, back to OITNB.
21 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>

    Author

    Waitress-wannabe. Baking hobbyist. Doggy mommy. Baking pies of all kinds inspired by the movie and musical WAITRESS.

    Archives

    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016

    Categories

    All
    Bacon
    Blueberry
    Breakfast Pies
    Cake Pies
    Cherry
    Coconut
    Cream Pies
    Crumble
    Fruit Pies
    Lemon
    Maple
    Marshmallow
    Mermaid
    Peach
    Pear
    Pies In Jars
    Pineapple
    Potato
    Quiche Pies
    Raspberry
    Rhubarb
    Strawberry
    Waitress Musical Pies

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • The Recipes
  • "Waitress" Pies
  • Contact